A delight for devotees, impenetrable as ever for outsiders. No change there, then.
Jon Hotten Classic Rock
Published October 13, 2010
Of the three great pillars of prog rock – Yes, Genesis and Pink Floyd – Yes were the real pointy-heads, the proggers’ prog rock band, the band whose excesses in the studio and the concert hall were most often cited by advocates of punk as the kind of elitist, musicianly outpourings that they had arrived to eradicate.
Fast forward three decades and here is a lavishly packaged four-CD and DVD set of many of Yes’s grandest, proggiest moments. Their music has endured, and will continue to do so, and the reason is obvious. They are the best at what they do. That is their riposte to critical unfashionability, to all of the jibes and the jokes and the opprobrium in the press.
It’s important to divide the band and the music at this point. While the music is ever-present, Yes’s famously internecene conflicts have meant that its players are more transitory. Sixteen men have passed through the band, many of them several times. Keys To Ascension is the reissue of live and studio recordings made by a reunion of the Anderson-Howe-Squire-Wakeman-White line-up in California in 1995, a formidable combo of originals giving the music its due and full weight. They had travelled to San Luis Obispo, Jon Anderson’s home, to record a handful of studio tracks and play some shows at the Fremont Theatre. The gigs covered most of their vast and forbidding catalogue and provided enough material for two live sets, released a year apart and augmented by those new tunes. Along with a concert film transferred from video, they are collected here for the first time.
They remain a delight for devotees, and just as impenetrable as ever for outsiders. A lengthy and reflective take on Siberian Khatru begins proceedings, followed quickly by a mere 20 minutes of The Revealing Science Of God from Yes’s most divisive album, Tales From Topographic Oceans. It’s a one-two that sorts the men from the boys, and it’s quickly followed by Going For The One’s centrepiece Awaken, perhaps Yes’s finest moment, and wonderfully rendered here. The second live disc offers a crowd-pleasing I’ve Seen All Good People and a majestic Closer To The Edge, in which all the odd glory of this band is apparent. You can trust Louder Our experienced team has worked for some of the biggest brands in music. From testing headphones to reviewing albums, our experts aim to create reviews you can trust. Find out more about how we review.
Of the three great pillars of prog rock – Yes, Genesis and Pink Floyd – Yes were the real pointy-heads, the proggers’ prog rock band, the band whose excesses in the studio and the concert hall were most often cited by advocates of punk as the kind of elitist, musicianly outpourings that they had arrived to eradicate.
Fast forward three decades and here is a lavishly packaged four-CD and DVD set of many of Yes’s grandest, proggiest moments. Their music has endured, and will continue to do so, and the reason is obvious. They are the best at what they do. That is their riposte to critical unfashionability, to all of the jibes and the jokes and the opprobrium in the press.
It’s important to divide the band and the music at this point. While the music is ever-present, Yes’s famously internecene conflicts have meant that its players are more transitory. Sixteen men have passed through the band, many of them several times. Keys To Ascension is the reissue of live and studio recordings made by a reunion of the Anderson-Howe-Squire-Wakeman-White line-up in California in 1995, a formidable combo of originals giving the music its due and full weight. They had travelled to San Luis Obispo, Jon Anderson’s home, to record a handful of studio tracks and play some shows at the Fremont Theatre. The gigs covered most of their vast and forbidding catalogue and provided enough material for two live sets, released a year apart and augmented by those new tunes. Along with a concert film transferred from video, they are collected here for the first time.
They remain a delight for devotees, and just as impenetrable as ever for outsiders. A lengthy and reflective take on Siberian Khatru begins proceedings, followed quickly by a mere 20 minutes of The Revealing Science Of God from Yes’s most divisive album, Tales From Topographic Oceans. It’s a one-two that sorts the men from the boys, and it’s quickly followed by Going For The One’s centrepiece Awaken, perhaps Yes’s finest moment, and wonderfully rendered here. The second live disc offers a crowd-pleasing I’ve Seen All Good People and a majestic Closer To The Edge, in which all the odd glory of this band is apparent.
The studio songs would have made a more than acceptable album; they are sharp, edgy and demanding. The line-up split almost immediately, of course. ’Twas ever thus.
Once Thought Of As The Future Of Music, The Birotron Attempts To Make A Return
By William Weir
PUBLISHED: January 18, 2010 at 5:00 a.m. | UPDATED: September 23, 2021 at 11:33 p.m.
Paul McCartney wanted one, the story goes; so did Led Zeppelin. Promoted in the 1970s as the “orchestra at your fingertips,” it was an unlikely combination of a piano keyboard and a series of 8-track tape players cobbled together in a Wallingford garage by an unemployed musician with no mechanical experience.
The Birotron was going to revolutionize music, and local papers hailed the Wallingford resident as the next Les Paul or Robert Moog. “Birotron Starts Tremor in Rock World: Ragged Inventor Awaits Riches,” read one headline. More than 30 years later, only six Birotrons are known to exist. Its appearance on record has been limited to a handful of albums, including two by the progressive rock band Yes.
But the Birotron has never been completely forgotten. The instrument often described as “ill-fated” has received renewed interest in recent years. Writer Paul Collins detailed the history of the Birotron a few years ago in the literary magazine “The Believer.” David Biro and his creation appear in the 2009 documentary “Mellodrama” (the DVD will be released this week). And there’s talk of reviving the Birotron for real.
Part of this might have to do with the “what if?” factor; had the Birotron succeeded, how would it have changed pop music? Biro says he’s surprised by the continuing interest.
“When I first got the idea for it, I only planned on making one for myself,” Biro says. “Making money had nothing to do with it. I wanted it to help further my musical career, but instead it ended up sidetracking my career to the point of no return.”
Cult status, of course, doesn’t pay bills. Today, Biro lives in a mobile home in Bayou George, Fla. He’s been unemployed for the past few months after the car upholstering business he worked for folded.
“It didn’t fail because it was a bad idea,” says David Kean, an electronic music historian and owner of Mellotronics in Calgary. “It didn’t fail because it was poorly designed. It failed because Biro counted on the fortunes of a rock star, and that’s always a dicey proposition.”
That rock star was Yes keyboardist Rick Wakeman, whose flashy style made the synthesizer seem as cool as the electric guitar in the early 1970s. The lives of the two 20-something men – one an out-of-work factory worker, the other a British musician known for elaborate stage costumes, would soon intersect to create an odd chapter in music history.
Biro first saw Wakeman perform in 1973 in Wallingford and was immediately star-struck. With binoculars, he analyzed Wakeman’s keyboard setup and committed it to memory. Wakeman had a Mellotron, so Biro also wanted one.
Considered one of the earliest music samplers, the Mellotron’s tones come from prerecorded tapes of other instruments. Press a key and, voila! Cello sounds, organ sounds, choir sounds. But the limitations of pre-digital technology made the tones sound like, well, recordings. Biro balked at spending $3,500 for it.
“I think I literally said, ‘I could do better than this in my father’s garage,'” says Biro, now 60. So with a $400 unemployment check, he bought 19 used 8-track players and got to work in his father’s garage. He spent more than 100 hours chopping up and reassembling the keyboard of an upright piano. He opened up 8-track cartridges and replaced the tapes with recordings he made from the Mellotron. Biro had no formal mechanical training, and the process was an arduous one.
“I remember when I got the first two notes, I plugged in the keyboard and played them, and went ‘woah!,'” he says. “And in a few days, I could play a whole chord.”
Because each key sounded the tape loop of an 8-track cartridge, Birotron notes lasted indefinitely. The Mellotron’s notes lasted only 8 seconds before the tapes had to rewind.
He played it for the members of his Meriden-based hard rock band, Blackwood. One suggested showing it to Wakeman. Biro laughed. Rick Wakeman! It could never happen. But his band’s manager was able to set up a meeting after a show at the New Haven Coliseum in October 1974. Biro threw his invention into the trunk of his Pinto and drove to the Coliseum.
“The escalators were all going down, so I had to run up the friggin’ escalators, seven stories, as fast I could while carrying this thing,” he says.
Backstage, Wakeman gave it a go. He smiled.
“He said, ‘How would you like to make some money with this?'” Biro recalls. “It was surreal, I was on cloud one hundred and ninety-nine. I couldn’t believe it was happening. He was my idol.”
Wakeman also remembers the meeting.
“The Birotron I loved when I first saw it, because it solved a lot of the problems that the Mellotron had, and I could see a future in it,” he said in an e-mail.
Within two months, Biro was in London, part of Birotronics Ltd., Wakeman’s newly minted company. Word got out about the new instrument.
“Everybody who was anybody wanted one,” Biro says. The Beach Boys and Paul McCartney expressed interest, he says. One of his favorite memories is discussing the Birotron over the phone with John Paul Jones of Led Zeppelin.
But after many delays in the instrument’s launch, Biro felt increasingly shut out of the process. “It kind of got out of my control.”
The Birotron’s Downfall
Biro remembers razzing Wakeman about his many marriages. Wakeman was going through an especially costly divorce at the time, a serious drain on funds. But Wakeman’s love life alone didn’t kill the Birotron. The prototype bore a flaw not in Biro’s original design: The 8-track players were placed horizontally, instead of vertically. “Eight-track tapes don’t like standing like that,” he says. “For whatever reason, the tapes jam up.”
But it was digital technology that finally killed the Birotron. The new music samplers boasted sounds much closer to the original sources, and Wakeman figured their product was obsolete. Production of the Birotron, which would have retailed for about $3,000, stopped altogether. About a dozen were made – numbers vary depending on whom you ask. Wakeman had one, but it was stolen.
In 2005, the Times of London reported that one Birotron owner sold his for $35,000. Biro, who owns one, doubts he could get that kind of money for his in this economy.
Craig Wuest of Atlanta is another Birotron owner. He got his from a former member of the German electronic band Tangerine Dream. Wuest’s old band, Earthstar, is one of the few to commit the instrument’s sounds to a commercial recording.
“I was taken by the Birotron because it doesn’t sound like anything else, it just doesn’t,” he says, adding that he doesn’t play it for fear of wearing out the instrument’s parts.
Wakeman and Biro last saw each other in 1994 and speak fondly of each other. Wakeman also remembers the Birotron fondly, even though “it almost bankrupted me.” The musician says he invested “a small fortune” in the instrument, but won’t specify how much.
Biro tried working out a deal in the U.S. with some Stratford entrepreneurs. That deal was killed by the recession, but Biro earned $5,000 from it, the only money he has made off the Birotron.
But the unique Birotron chorus sound lives on, thanks to the instrument that inspired it. Streetly Electronics, a company based in the United Kingdom, offers it as part of its catalogs of tapes for the Mellotron. The Canadian band Arcade Fire uses it on the soundtrack it recorded for the recent film “The Box.” Does Biro get royalties?
“No, no, of course not!” he says, laughing. “Why do you think I’m broke?”
Chris Dale, a Birotron enthusiast in Toronto who befriended Biro some years ago, thinks that the Birotron could be revived in some form – perhaps as digital sounds that could be downloaded for a fee. “It would be great if Dave could make some money off this,” he says. “I’d like to see the whole problem redeem itself.”
He says there’s enough curiosity about the Birotron to make it work.
“It would have been interesting to see how all these musicians would have used this instrument,” he says. “It’s this unexplored thing that never had a chance to emerge.”
Hear a sample of the Birotron sound featured on the Yes album Tormato, “On the Silent Wings of Freedom,” at courant.com/birotron.
Trevor Horn’s epic pop productions are rooted in an early infatuation with prog rock. “In my twenties I took some LSD and listened to music hour after hour. Most of the opinions I hold today were formed then,” he tells ANDREW HARRISON
IN TREVOR HORN’S SANCTORUM ABOVE Ladbroke Grove’s Sarm West Studios, in the kitchenette behind the lounge with the over-stuffed sofas and the family pictures and the scented candles, there’s a frame letter on the wall. It is dated 1983.
Dear Sir, it reads, We strongly object to receiving filth through the post. If there is anything else of the nature of Frankie Goes To Hollywood in the pipeline then please cross this shop off your mailing list. From A To Z Records, Worthing, Sussex.
Sharing the frame is the 7-inch cover of Relax. Yvonne Gilbert’s infamous illustration of the muscular gimp in leather undies and a spike heeled dollybird wearing no drawers at all is now bleached and yellowing with age. Trevor Horn, 61 this year, regards it with a mixture of nostalgia and disbelief, as if considering it anew. “We have so many complaints, so many complaints…” he mutters. Complaints about the original 12-inch Sex Mix of Relax, for instance, in which producer Horn and his studio colleagues celebrated finally cracking this notorious difficult recording by getting stoned and making a completely obscene 16-minute version full of squelches and moans, with none of the original song on it at all. “We had angry letters from gay clubs,” he says. “‘You think this is a joke? You think this is what we’re about?’ I probably did go too far on that one.” Then he brightens. “Worth a lot of money now, though. George Michael brought the last one. Got it in a shop in Borehamwood.”
Music fans all grow up with fantasy band line-ups in their heads. I only ever had a fantasy producer in mine. From The Buggles and ABC through the three great bands on his label Zang Tuum Tumb — Frankie, The Art Of Noise and Propaganda — Trevor Horn raised the bar of what pop could do so high that we could barely see it. He made me listen to Yes (Owner Of A Lonely Heart = TUNE) and with the Malcolm McLaren album Duck Rock he showed me that world music was not just for geography teachers but was, in fact, other people’s pop music. I realised years later that Horn’s signature sound — cosmic and grand but relentlessly danceable — came from his love of the most taboo music of the 1980s, prog rock. I wanted Trevor Horn to produce everything, preferably as a 14-minute-long disco mix.
His first truly massive hit was Video Killed The Radio Star; among his most recent releases is the Robbie Williams album Reality Killed The Video Star. Horn’s story stretches from the end of the Top Rank showband era into the digital present and beyond. It seems a good time to talk to him, not just because of the indelible mark that Horn has made on pop music but because of the great affection in which he is help too.
The latter came to the fore in 2006 after the tragic accident that befell Jill Sinclair, Trevor’s wife since 1980 and his formidable business partner. Their son was practising with an air gun and accidentally hit his mother in the neck, piercing an artery. The resulting blood loss put her in a coma. Trevor does not like to talk about his wife in interviews but confirms that it’s unlikely that she will make any significant recovery. It would be a bitterly cruel blow even if Jill Sinclair had not been, to a large extent, the unstoppable business drive behind Trevor’s artistic talent. “It’s funny,” he says after thinking for a few moments. “I really cried when I heard about Roy, from Siegfried & Roy, being attacked by their tiger. He’s in the same situation. Basically you’re in a coma for the rest of your life. I think the last thing he said was, ‘Don’t shoot the tiger. It’s not the tiger’s fault.’” He pauses. “What an amazing thing to say.”
TREVOR HORN WAS BORN IN DURHAM AND HIS voice retains a slight Geordie lilt, mellowed with a few transatlantic notes. He knows more about music than God does and is capable of going into impassioned digressions about it. For instance: the term “classical” is nonsense because all that music was written for the moment, as jigs and reels for instant consumption; the orchestra is the result of the mass-production of instruments that could stay in tune and is therefore directly related to Fairlight and Roland; and a medieval cathedral is, among other things, a fantastic reverb unit. He is surprisingly defensive about his beloved prog.
“What it all comes down to,” he says eventually, “is that when I was in my twenties I took some LSD and all I did was listen to music for hour after hour. Most of the opinions that I still hold today were formed then. My paradigm for a record was always putting on a pair of headphones and getting lost in it; the record taking you on a journey. All the records I liked did that. I liked progressive music because progressive means you haven’t given up.
“Let’s face it, most musical forms have an inspired creator that starts them off and then they settle into ‘in the style of’. The only form of music that isn’t conservative is pop music. Pop is like hamburgers. It takes in a bit of everything around it. It’s whatever you can get normal people to buy. How many modern symphonies do you ever listen to? We listen to Tchaikovksy, Mozart or Debussy, and it’s wonderful but it’s been done, almost to perfection. Pop’s not like that. Pop changes.”
Trevor Horn hated music at school. But when he turned eight everyone was given a recorder and made to learn it. Trevor had never imagined he might enjoy music before. His father, an engineer by day, played double bass five nights a week in a semi-pro dance outfit called The Joe Clark Band — this was where he met Trevor’s mother — and he taught Trevor how to play Way Down Upon The Swanee River on the double bass. Then Trevor began to work out the bass for himself. By the age of 12 he was deputising for his father if Horn Senior arrived late for a gig. “The band would tolerate me,” he says. This was in 1962, just as The Beatles were about to happen. “Then I became a classic Beatles casualty.
“I loved records, and I was interested in how things sounded. I was fascinated by pictures in the Melody Maker of people wearing headphones in recording studios. I dreamed of wearing them myself. It looked like the most exciting thing that anyone could ever do.
And even when I was 14 I could tell there was a difference between The Beatles when they played on Sunday Night At The London Palladium and the records. Why did they sound so different? The Beatles sounded kind of rough when they were live. I could tell they were a little out of tune. The records were so much better and I was always fascinated by those differences early on.” He became a professional musician the day he got fired from his last proper job, as a “progress chaser” in a plastic bag factory. Aged 18 he went from an office job to working in a Top Rank ballroom six nights a week on three times as much money. “It was fantastic,” he says, still energised. “Back then, if someone was a good reader, we’d say he could read fly shit off a lampshade. I couldn’t quite do that but I wasn’t a bad bass player. That was how I earned a living.”
Years as a jobbing musician ensued. He played in British disco star Tina Charles’ band, where he met future Buggles partner Geoff Downes and also became Tina’s boyfriend. He built a studio of his own in Leicester while playing seven nights a week in Bailey’s club in the city to pay the rent. But work was hard to come by. He and his colleagues would tinker with local artists’ songs and once made a record for Leicester City FC. At one session, a keyboard player friend called Bill Coleman told him, “Trevor, what you’re doing is called being a record producer.”
“It was one of those great moments when I thought, ‘Obviously that’s what I do,’” says Trevor. “I love it so much, it must be my thing. Bill told me I’d have to give up the bass, and he was dead right.” It would be six years before Horn got a hit, a pop-reggae-funk single by Dan-I called Monkey Chop that got to number 17 in 1979.
His next hit would be of a different order altogether. It was Trevor’s friend and writing partner Bruce Woolley who came up with the line “I heard you on the wireless back in ‘52". The two would often talk about the radio shows of their childhoods — The Clitheroe Kid, Educating Archie, Workers’ Playtime — and they were reading a lot of JG Ballard too. Horn, Woolley and Geoff Downes began to imagine a state-of-the-art pop group with a nostalgic streak. The name would be a corruption of The Beatles. They thought of issuing badges that said “I passed on The Buggles.”
“I was a misfit at the time,” says Trevor. “My stuff just sounded weird. I couldn’t make records like Elton John and I hated punk — I thought they were all shit musicians, although I grew to understand it in retrospect. I envied those guys who played with Elton John. They seemed so unassailable. What am I going to ever do that’s going to get close to that? I don’t have a great feel or a great blues voice. Then I heard Kraftwerk’s The Man Machine and I thought, that’s it! A mechanised rhythm section, a band where you’re never old-fashioned, where you don’t have to emote. It sounded so new and exciting, so full of potential.”
Trevor found himself supplying the second line, “…lying awake intently tuning in on you”, and Video Killed The Radio Star was completed in an afternoon. Woolley had signed another deal, so it fell to Trevor to sing the song, and Bruce suggested he treat his voice to sound like it was coming out of a radio. “Sometimes when you start something you get an idea pretty quickly that it’s going to work,” Trevor recalls. “There was a moment when Geoffrey played a little French horn thing on the synth and I just knew it was the best thing I’d ever done, that it was going to be big.” Video Killed The Radio Star transformed Horn from struggling producer to number-one star in 16 countries, and from penury to sudden wealth. “It changed my life completely,” he says.
He celebrated with a new pair of glasses — the giant round ones that became a trademark.
He pinched the idea from Elvis Costello and collected them from an opticians on Sloane Square on the way to a Buggles gig. When he came out wearing them Geoff Downes was amazed. Was Trevor really going to wear them? “Yes,” he replied solemnly. “It’s a new era. I’m a Buggle now.” At this point the story takes a sudden lurch sideways as Horn and Downes, having finally achieved pop stardom, opt to join Yes instead. This is akin to The Verve deciding they need some fresh blood today, and proceeding to draft in Calvin Harris and Dizzee Rascal.
“That was kind of an insane thing to do,” Trevor admits. “I’d never been up close to a massive rock band before. I’d been playing music since I was 11 but when we were invited into rehearsals with them, it was an eye-opener. They were something else. They’d be playing together and it would be sort of OK, and then somebody would wake up and they’d go into this other mode. I’d never heard anything like it. They were really playing, on some level that I don’t think even they understood.”
Long-time Yes fans, he and Downes gradually understood that they were invited not as guests but as replacements for Rick Wakeman and Jon Anderson. For years afterwards Horn had a recurring nightmare that he was in a limo on the way to Madison Square Garden with Yes’s Chris Squire telling him they were going to play Parallels that night, over Trevor’s protests that he couldn’t sing it. He made the Drama album with Yes and left afterwards, returning to produce 90125 and Owner Of A Lonely Heart years later. Geoff Downes decided to stay.
“And quite a few people thought that that was the end of it for me,” says Horn. “But I thought, ‘Well at least my wife can manage me now. No more conflict of interest.’” Jill Sinclair’s first piece of advice: stop trying to be an artist and concentrate on producing. If you’re an artist you’ll always be second division. But if you’re a producer you’ll become the best in the world.
THERE’S A WIDELY HELD belief, fostered by stories about Frankie, that the Horn Method entails preventing a band from playing on their own records. This gets a laugh from Trevor, who explains that sometimes it’s more about dismantling the group and their music to examine every little piece, and then building it up again. Its first true application, he says, was ABC’s spectacular Lexicon Of Love in 1982, where a promising Brit-funk band were transformed by work and will into a paragon of pop music.
“They were very ambitious,” he says. “We’d recorded one full-band version of Poison Arrow and I asked Martin Fry, ‘Is this what you had in mind or do you want it better than this?’ He said, ‘We want it as good as it can possibly be. We want to compete with the Americans.’ So I told them that if that’s what they wanted, we were going to have to start again.” Horn reprogrammed all the music into sequencers and the band played along until they were metronomically sharp. Some members could do it and others could not. “I did dismantle the band a bit, and I still regret it because I paid a high price for it. I got ABC to change bass players. They had the English band syndrome: one of the guys isn’t as good as all the others. I guess you could say that lost me the chance of ever producing U2. Blackwell wanted me to do it but they were scared that I would split the band.”
The Lexicon Of Love and Malcolm McLaren’s concurrent world tour of pop Duck Rock also brought into the picture the backroom musicians who would define much of Horn’s future — string arranger Anne Dudley, engineer-musician Gary Langan and JJ Jeczalik, Geoff Downes’ former roadie who became the high priest of mysterious new instrument the Fairlight. Byproducts of their experimentation with the Fairlight became the music of The Art Of Noise.
J made a loop from Alan White’s drums and that became Beat Box — thus it was that the archetypal pounding hip hop beat of the synthetic ‘80s came from Yes’s drummer. Meanwhile, Horn and Jill bought Island’s Basing Street Studios from Chris Blackwell in a deal that also gave them a record label to be distributed through Island. They called the studio Sarm West. Horn’s “naive” idea was that his record company could nurture artists more closely than a major label. “I had ridiculous ideas of what a record label should be,” he says. “I thought it would be ajoyous creative commune — and of course it’s not.” He did, however, manage to push the label’s look-and-feel to the ultimate by recruiting NME writer Paul Morley to control its aesthetic. They christened it Zang Tuum Tumb, borrowing the title from a Futurist poem and transforming it into the classic capitalist three-letter initials, ZTT. Morley had written “the worst hatchet job anyone could ever do” on The Buggles but subsequently fell in love with Dollar and ABC.
“He interviewed me and part of it ended up in Pseud’s Corner in Private Eye,” says Horn. “Quite an achievement, really. He made me seem more erudite than I was. I thought, ‘This is what writers do. They romanticise what they see.’ The more I thought about the label the more I wanted Morley to design it. He did, and we had an incredible couple of years.”
Apart from an Art Of Noise 12-inch, ZTT’s first signing was a Liverpool band Horn had seen on C4’s The Tube. “I thought the drummer was interesting, with his little Hitler moustache and fuzzy hair, and the beat — boof! boof! — it was a shagging beat. I heard them again on Kid Jensen and told my wife that it didn’t matter what it took, we were going to sign them. That’s when we found out that everybody else had turned them down anyway.”
With its eventual court case, the story of Frankie is often taken as a parable of what onerous contracts can do to a band. Trevor thinks this reading is unfair on him. He had, after all, signed them on the strength of a demo only to find that gifted guitarist Jed O’Toole had been replaced by Brian “Nasher” Nash, “a good-looking kid, very important to the psychological make-up of Frankie, but he couldn’t play guitar very well. What am I supposed to do?”
The making of Relax has gone down in the annals of tortuous recording. The song went through four discrete versions before it became the monster that ate 1984. In the first version Horn tried to record it as the band played it live. “It was pretty awful,” he says, “because Nasher couldn’t really play.” For the second attempt Horn assembled a group of session players, including Ian Dury’s band The Blockheads, which was “OK but kind of tame”. The third attempt at Relax took weeks and led Horn into misery, but an arrangement for Frankie’s version of Ferry Cross The Mersey was going much better. Horn and keyboard player Andy Richards had stumbled on a low-end pumping rhythm on the Fairlight. “And then a bunch of things all happened at the same time.”
A friend had given Horn a Nepalese Temple Ball- a lump of dope — which he smoked, getting “quite a bit further out than I usually get” and experiencing a moment of clarity. Yes, the third version of Relax was rubbish, but he had quality musicians with him. The band had gone home to Liverpool. They might as well have another go, and they might as well base it around that pelvic-thrust rhythm that was sitting on the Fairlight. In his enhanced state Horn perceived a counter-rhythm in the song that conjured up a traditional English country dance — in amongst the massive pop orgy, a group of Morris dancers. Andy Richardson was an absolute nut with the Jupiter 8. Incredible noises. I told him I wanted a massive orgasm on there and Andy gave us those noises. The irony is that there’s nothing on there that The Lads couldn’t play.
It’s sad that they weren’t there to play it themselves but that’s the way it goes sometimes.” In the end they completed Relax in a single take. At llpm Holly Johnson arrived at the studio. “It’s changed,” Trevor told him. “How much?” “Completely.” “Oh no. Not again.”
The hit version of Relax ignited ZTT’s imperial period, when it seemed they could do no wrong. Quincy Jones called Horn asking to buy the album by their third key signing, the German industrial pop band Propaganda, for America. “He was very surprised that I knew all his old stuff like Smackwater Jack. I was on the phone with him for an hour. I wanted to know what it was like to work with Sinatra. And if you listen to Michael Jackson around that time, ‘85-86, he started to sound a lot like Propaganda…” Even the faceless Art Of Noise began to have hits. The label seemed to have discovered a foolproof formula for producing perfect pop music.
They had, for instance, stumbled upon the idea of perpetually remixing a current release to keep it selling, an idea they built into their plan for Frankie’s second single Two Tribes. The initial 12-inch featured Patrick Allen, unmistakable voice of a thousand Public Information Films, reading from the government’s Protect And Survive films and from a record that radio stations were supposed to play in the event of a nuclear attack. When Allen read the script he immediately asked, “Where did you get this? You’re not supposed to have this.” He had been required to sign the Official Secrets Act when he recorded the original. Horn and Morley were crestfallen. Did that mean he wouldn’t record the Frankie voiceover? Allen thought for a moment and then said, “No, sod it,” and began the recording. Finally Morley suggested that Allen speak the words, “Mine is the last voice that you will ever hear.”
“And when he did it,” says Horn, “you could see that it really affected him. It was chilling, even to him.” This is how summer 1984 saw Britain’s radios and dancefloor fill with messages about the end of the world.
INEVITABLY ZTT COULDN’T LAST. THE BANDS WERE on lousy deals, says Horn, because ZTT itself was on a lousy deal. “We were earning half of what a record label ought to be on,” he says. “I know I’d be able to handle the personalities better now. With 30 years of experience. I had no idea how awful it was going to get.”
Frankie fell out and split in early 1987. ZTT tried to hold Holly Johnson to a solo contract but lost an embarrassing court case for restraint of trade. “In hindsight,” says Horn diplomatically, “we should have probably let him go.” Meanwhile The Art Of Noise were increasingly annoyed by Morley’s conceptual antics and open to voices that told them they were a hit band who ought to have been making more money. Propaganda wanted a better deal too and found one, with Virgin, but their next album was an insipid failure compared to their ZTT album A Secret Wish. ZTT would sign other successful acts (Seal, 808 State) but their infallible years were behind them.
There was also a sense that times were changing around Horn in the late 1980s. The home recording and DIY ethics of the Summer of Love were in, grandeur and scope were out. Horn admits that he resented house music somewhat. “It might have been because I got tired of people criticising me because my records sounded good,” he says. “I thought Relax sounded trashy but I realised afterwards that what I was hearing was a modern record, for the first time. It didn’t have any fidelity. It was samples and ratty little guitar sounds. That was the future. But rave music probably annoyed me more in the ‘90s. By the end of the ‘80s I was in America. I was a bit tired of here. In LA there was a nice feeling of being a small fish in a big pond.”
The work he’s done since is just as successful but inevitably less controversial — Seal, Charlotte Church, Paul McCartney, the Pet Shop Boys’ best album for a decade, Fundamental, and, uncharacteristically, Belle & Sebastian, the indie-est band on earth, whom Horn says “needed very very little production, just a good engineer and someone to tell them when a take is a good one”. But do we need record producers in an era when studios themselves are disappearing?
“You’ll always need record producers,” he says calmly. “If you’re a young artist you learn how to entertain in the live context, but when you come in here it’s intimidating. The record you make is going to determine your career. I’m sure there were a lot of bands around in the ‘70s who could play as well as The Eagles, but The Eagles were the ones who made great records. A recording studio is a strange place, as much psychologically as technically, and if you come in without the right sort of help you can get it wrong — possibly in some way you never even dreamt of.
“Sometimes,” says Trevor Horn, “All people need from a record producer is a voice to say, ‘That’s great, it’s finished. You’re done.’”
The unreleased second Buggies album ADVENTURES IN MODERN RECORDING and Frankie Goes To Hollywood’s WELCOME TO THE PLEASUREDOME are both out now as Deluxe Edition CDs
Forgotten Yesterdays
Updates
Downloads
Memorabilia
Discography
Yes Statistics
About Us
Home
Yes (2010)
Overview
Reviews (3)