Thank you Travis you confirmed for me that it was 3 encores that night! I remember that by the second encore many people had left and we were able to move right up to the front of the theater. We actually stood on the front row seats in front of Squire and their playing was just unbelievable. Even though there weren't a lot of people left when they did the final encore, they played as if they were at a large concert hall. It was pure magic and I will never forget how incredible the whole thing was.
I get great satisfaction from just seeing them live, and have memorable songs from different shows:
South Side of The Sky - 3rd encore, Ritz Theater Staten Is.